Creating Fictional Characters—Part 2: Finding and Creating Characters

June 17, 2009 by Lillie 

DSCN5526Now we know what characters are. How do you come up with the characters for your novel or short story?

In Creating Characters: How to Build Story People, Dwight Swain says

You start from a foundation of your fantasies and feelings. Because the character you can’t fantasize and feel with will fail.  … 

In other words, you hunt till you find one whose looks you like … one who fits your private standards.

Sometimes it’s tempting to base a character on a real person, but that’s not a good idea. No two people—or characters—are alike. If you try to create a character just like someone you know, you won’t have the freedom to create the perfect character for your story.

However, using individual traits and characteristics from real people works well. Observe people—at home, at work, in the mall, in the media, everywhere you go. Use what you observe to create composite characters. Ask yourself, “What if …” What if  someone had hair like your mother’s, a facial tic like someone you saw in the office supply store, the voice pattern of your neighbor from another state, and the bubbly personality of a co-worker? And what if that person was a fifth degree black belt in karate?

Make your characters fit your story—people who can do interesting things and still be credible. If you’re writing an amateur sleuth mystery, your sleuth has to have some reason or motivation to solve the crime. Maybe she has an insatiable curiosity, has always been intrigued by a puzzle. Your action-adventure hero needs to have the physical and personal traits to enjoy adventure, or he must have some strong motivation to overcome his limitations.

Real people don’t always act consistently and don’t always know why they do what they do, but they rationalize their behavior. Rationalization provides plausible (but not necessarily true) reasons for actions, in life and fiction. Even when characters’ actions aren’t logical, the characters have to feel they are justified.

Just as in real life, we form dominant impressions of characters based on what we see:

  • Sex – woman, man, girl, boy
  • Age – young, old, 18-years-old, baby, teenager
  • Vocation – doctor, nurse, housewife, bag lady, construction worker, lawyer
  • Manner – surly, bubbly, sloppy, friendly, pompous, fun-loving

But if you built characters with dominant impressions only, they would be shallow and flat characters, not the dynamic, three-dimensional characters main characters should be.

In a list of do’s and don’ts for character development, Holly Lisle, author of Holly Lisle’s Create A Character Clinic, recommends:

Do start developing your character by giving him a problem, a dramatic need, a compulsion.

 Now you’re starting to make your character interesting. A woman who is a young lawyer with a fun-loving manner is a stereotype. A woman who is a young lawyer with a fun-loving manner and a hatred of drunk drivers because her parents were killed by a drunk driver who is assigned by her law firm to defend a man accused of drunk driving—that’s an interesting character.

In my novel Dream or Destiny, Marilee Anderson is a business consultant who is strong and confident in her business but quiet and shy in her personal life. She dreads being in the public eye, and, more than anything, she hates being mocked for her psychic abilities. Then she has a dream that puts her in the spotlight in a sensational murder case, a target of media attention and public ridicule for her dream.

The next installment will cover revealing character and point of view.

Creative Commons License photo credit: Sweet One

Comments

49 Responses to “Creating Fictional Characters—Part 2: Finding and Creating Characters”

  1. wilson says:

    Lillie, beside of the sex, age, vocation and manner, maybe the appearance, such as bold, blonde hair, red hair, overweight, slim and other characteristics would be good for describing the characters, isn’t it?
    .-= wilson´s last blog ..Only Take Coughing Medicine When Necessary! =-.

    • Lillie says:

      wilson,

      You’re getting ahead of me. :-) We’ll get to fleshing out characters with tags and descriptions in a couple more installments. Glad you’re thinking and figuring things out for yourself.

  2. Charlie Pitt says:

    I guess story comes first in a mind…and while I try to narrate it to myself, characters start popping up..I constantly make the change till I start feeling as if the character is not fictitious and story is a real evidence!

    • Lillie says:

      Charlie,

      It sounds like you have a good mix of plot and character, which is excellent. You are plot-driven in that you begin with the plot, but you develop your characters well too.

  3. Robert Fluke says:

    I have always used characters partially based upon people I know. Interesting the author suggest the opposite. The next time I write some fiction I will try it the other way, if I can get my mind to comply.

    • Lillie says:

      Robert,

      When you say you create characters “partially” based on people you know, you may not be far off base. The main problem with using real people as characters is that most people try to duplicate the person, and the character doesn’t develop throughout the story (which we’ll discuss in a future installment). Your story is hindered trying to fit a real person into the plot rather than creating the perfect character for the story.

      Another problem with using real people is that none of us are perfect (and your characters shouldn’t be, either). If the real person you are using as a model reads your story, they may not like your portraying their bad habits and unpleasant characteristics.

      You may find it helpful to start with a real person as a model for your character and create the character “partially” based on the person. My advice is NOT that you never to use a real person at all but that you not to try to make your character identical to the person.

  4. I totally agree with not basing a character on a real person because it tends to take away from your imagination, even though it may seem a good idea at the time. If you have a real person in mind, then I don’t think that you can take your character where you want it to go.

    • Lillie says:

      C,

      That’s exactly right. You’re hampered into trying to make the character like the person rather than developing your character naturally.

  5. Stephen from free iPod says:

    I absolutely see your points. The lawyer example demonstrates the point well. Only it takes some good imagination to creat a character. Having said that, it takes some good imagination to write a book!

  6. yle from KKindel DX says:

    Thank you for your insights, Lillie.

    I’ve always wanted to write fiction, especially children’s stories. Now your ideas are giving me more confidence to give it a shot.

    Character creation was always what I would start with when deciding on an idea to write from. I don’t know if this is the best place to start, but it always seemed to be the place that I stopped, so I’ve never gotten very far.

    Also, if you wanted to write satire, would you say, for example, your “action-hero” might have the opposite characteristics of what a typical action hero has? Maybe he/she would be fat and lazy?

    • Lillie says:

      Kyle,

      As I mentioned in the first installment of the series, some writers start with character and some start with plot. Either way can work, though some types of writing tend to focus more on either plot or character.

      Regarding satire, yes, you could create a character the opposite of a stereotype, like a fat and lazy action hero.

  7. icole from nfashion indonesia says:

    wow,,you teach me from the basic.usually i am just imagine and voilla!!!its done,but many times its unstructured.thank you very much

    • Lillie says:

      nicole,

      Most of us probably start writing in an unstructured way, but the better you plan, the less rewriting you’ll have to do.

  8. According to me story is thing which comes to your mid at first and when you start working on it its your heart that tells you more and more on it. It tells how it could go well and and how i can become superb. Yet all depends on the power of imagination of the writer.

    • Lillie says:

      Luxury (if you wrote YourName@Keywords, I could address you as a real person, and you would still get your keyword link),

      With a name like Luxury Linens, I can see why you wouldn’t start with character. :-) Seriously, each writer has to write the way that works for them. And, as you say, imagination is key.

  9. Doina says:

    Thinking about the character is a good starting point, but I usually feel the need to start with the plot first. If I don’t know what will happen next, I feel like I’m writing useless stuff. I’m always searching for interesting actions, not so much people. I guess that if you want to focus more on people, than you’d have to be a very good writer to build up an interesting character, because the character stands only by itself, it has only feelings and thoughts and a history, it doesn’t actually do anything. You know, like in the introduction of the “Karamazov brothers”, were characters don’t do anything for about 50 pages or so, but it’s still one of the best books I’ve read.

    • Lillie says:

      Doina,

      Character doesn’t actually do anything? That’s not at all how I see it. Characters live the action—without characters nothing could happen. In character-driven books, characters grow and develop and change. That may not be so important in plot-driven books, but the character has to be appropriate for the story. You can’t have a good action-adventure if you don’t have an active, adventurous protagonist.

  10. nA says:

    actually, sometimes i feel terrible to find out character idea, but when i’ve got something briliant, it can’t stop me to write.. write.. more & more.. until it’s all finished…

  11. new war movies says:

    I agree to some extent that you shouldn’t base your characters on real people. But sometimes, basing characters on real people, taking their traits and combining them, can be very helpful.

    • Lillie says:

      new (if you wrote YourName@Keywords, I could address you as a real person instead of visualizing talking to a war movie, and you would still get your keyword link),

      I think you’re saying exactly what I said in the post. :-)

  12. Document Feed Scanner says:

    I usually try to think about the character first of all and what type of person they will be. Once I have a good idea of their characteristics and history, it makes writing a good plot and developing characters around them a lot easier.

    • Lillie says:

      Document (if you wrote YourName@Keywords, I could address you as real person, and you would still get your keyword link),

      What kind of characters does a document feed scanner create? Printers, scanners, and fax machines? I couldn’t resist that—I just can’t envision someone named Document Feed Scanner writing a book. :-)

  13. illmill from HowToStartABusiness says:

    Great advice! Creating fictional characters in writing takes a lot of imagination.

  14. AbbieMulder from SaveMarriageBook says:

    I love the part where you talk about creating composite characters! Brings me back to my childhood days, sitting at the mall waiting for my mom, and just staring at the people going by and imagining what would it be like if I took this person’s head and added it to that person’s body! Yup, I had a somewhat overworked imagination! (Still do!)

    • Lillie says:

      Abbie,

      Now that is creating a composite character. :-) I smiled visualizing a little girl sitting in the mall using her overactive imagination.

  15. Creating a character such as that is not very easy. You seem to have put great detail in your writing.
    .-= Wireless Outdoor Speakers´s last blog ..Choosing The Best Wireless Speakers for Your Needs =-.

    • Lillie says:

      Wireless Outdoor Speakers (if you wrote YourName@Keywords, I could address you as a real person, and you would still get your keyword link),

      Nothing about writing fiction is easy. It takes a lot of hard work to create a story that people enjoy reading.

  16. ndrej from Asports footwear says:

    “A woman who is a young lawyer with a fun-loving manner and a hatred of drunk drivers because her parents were killed by a drunk driver who is assigned by her law firm to defend a man accused of drunk driving—that’s an interesting character.”

    That’s exactly the characters that i find intriguing when I’m reading a book or watching a movie. I always hope their rational side will win and they’ll realise they have to let go of the past :) .

    • Lillie says:

      Andrej,

      Like you, I enjoy stories where the characters have to deal with their emotions and where they grow and change.

  17. [...] for Creating Fictional CharactersCreating Fictional Characters—Part 1: Characters Are Story PeopleCreating Fictional Characters—Part 2: Finding and Creating CharactersCreating Fictional Characters Part 3: Revealing Characters and Point of ViewCreating Fictional [...]

  18. indie says:

    Ya i also like the concept of characters being strong and can develope over time.
    .-= indie´s last blog ..Indie Music ! =-.

  19. celine from harley davidson handlebars says:

    I am starting to write now Lillie.I’ve just read that it is not a good idea to base the character in real person, I was just about to make the character resemble mine.. I guess it would be easy for me to write with that, but I think I have to change my idea and try to make a character which is distinct from anybody else..
    celine@harley davidson handlebars recently posted..Custom Harley handlebars- Wire them internally

    • Lillie says:

      celine,

      You can loosely base your character on someone you know, even yourself, but don’t try to make the character exactly like the real person. You don’t want to offend someone who might recognize themself, and you don’t want to be limited to make the character act or talk in a certain way. If you find it difficult to come up with totally original characters, base them on a composite of real people: language like one person, facial appearance like someone else, an odd habit of a different person, etc.

  20. Wow. cool tips to create a fictional character.
    But everyone can’t be as good as Stephen King or Dan Brown :P

    • Lillie says:

      Girish,

      No, not everyone can be as good as Stephen King or Dan Brown. But not all readers like to read Stephen King and Dan Brown, either. :-)

  21. Arvind Ranabhat from mallu says:

    Yes Lillie you are right. But I think that to make a book sell, one needs to be imaginative in writing and creating plots. And as you say, characters also play an important role.

    • Lillie says:

      Arvind,

      Different genres have varying degrees of emphasis on plot compared to character. In thrillers, plot takes center stage. In romance, character takes center stage. Mystery often requires a good balance of both. You’re right that both are important–the relative importance varies with the genre and with the specific story, though.

  22. Jerryl from Toilet Paper says:

    For a true to life story, characters and traits of a person in necessary for selecting a names. For an antagonists, we would like to give them a bad and evil names.

  23. Esther says:

    Really helpful, thank you!
    I am currently working on a novel, and these articles are great in the planning phase. :)
    Have you heard of the Snowflake Method? It helps me a lot. Some people say it kills the novel if you plan it too much, but I think for a good and coherent story it should be planned.
    (Sorry for my English if I had mistakes.)

    • Lillie says:

      Esther,

      I have never used the Snowflake Method, but I know many authors love it. Randy Ingermanson is an excellent writer, so obviously he knows what he’s doing when he gives writing advice. Some writers find they write most effectively when they do a lot of planning and organizing in advance, and others feel they write best when they “go with the flow.” There is no one right way to write–you just need to read what others recommend, experiment, and see what works for you. And you may change your style as you gain experience.

Leave a Reply

Please read the instructions below. For more information see my comment policy.

Please include your first name or nickname. This site uses KeywordLuv. See instructions below name field. If this is your first comment, it will be held for moderation. After your first comment is approved, future comments will not be moderated. If your comment doesn't appear within a day, e-mail Lillie—the comment may have been caught in spam.

This site uses KeywordLuv. Enter Your Name @ Your Keywords (Fill in the keywords you want to appear in your link) in the Name field to take advantage. The link will appear in the post though not in the preview; if you see a mistake after the comment is posted, you have 15 minutes to edit your comment.

CommentLuv badge

This site uses KeywordLuv. Enter YourName@YourKeywords in the Name field to take advantage.

You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

If you have not previously left a comment that has been approved, your comment will not appear until I have approved the first one.