POD: Part 2 – Pros and Cons of Self-Publishing with POD

October 30, 2007 by Lillie 

Table of contents for POD

  1. POD: Part 1 – What It Is
  2. POD: Part 2 – Pros and Cons of Self-Publishing with POD
  3. POD: Part 3 – Pros and Cons of Using a POD Subsidy Publisher
  4. POD: Part 4 – POD Publishers

In the last post, we talked about what POD is. Although POD (print on demand) is a digital printing technology, some publishers who use the technology call themselves POD publishers. We’ll address the pros and cons of self-publishing with POD in this post and the pros and cons of using a POD subsidy publisher in the next post.

Note, these are the pros and cons of printing with POD technology rather than an offset press for an author who has already chosen to self-publish. For the pros and cons of self-publishing, see What are the pros and cons of self-publishing?

Pros

  • You can start your self-publishing business with only a small investment for printing, though you will have other expenses as described in How much does self-publishing cost? POD printers (not publishers) usually charge a nominal set-up fee, then the unit cost per book remains the same regardless of how many books are ordered. Although you can start business with little or no inventory, I recommend you order enough books initially to send out review copies and have some books available to handsell.
  • You can test-market your book and make changes to your text. You can experiment with different covers or titles to see what sells best. If your book is on a topic where information changes often, you can update the information and start selling a new edition immediately without any concern about existing inventory.
  • You can save on the unit cost of books compared to doing an offset press run for small quantities; however, the unit cost goes down with larger quantities in offset printing and stays the same in POD.
  • You don’t have to maintain an inventory, which means you don’t have to fill your garage or spare bedroom with books or spend money to rent storage space.
  • You will use your own ISBN numbers and be in control of your book as the publisher of record in Books in Print for the book. This is true for self-published books regardless of the printing method, but it is not true of books published by subsidy POD companies.

Cons

  • If you expect to sell large quantities of books, you will pay a higher unit cost than if you used an offset printer for a larger print run.
  • The quality of printing varies, so be sure to ask for samples before contracting with a POD printer.
  • The higher cost of POD printing will make it difficult to sell your book through distribution channels such as bookstores and distributors, who usually require a 55% discount.

These are what I see as the major advantages and disadvantages of having your self-published book printed by a digital/print on demand printer.

Do you have experience with POD printing for a self-published book? What other pros and cons can you suggest?

Comments

RSS feed | Trackback URI

6 Comments »

2008-10-20 15:27:14

you really explained the nitty grities in detail, truly a knowledgeable article

Comment by Lillie
2008-10-20 17:50:08

The entire primer has this kind of detail. You can download the whole series in a free e-book.

 
 
Comment by Rodney Smith Subscribed to comments via email
2008-10-21 09:06:38

We recently used Lulu for a church project. Overall, the outcome was OK, but don’t think we’d use them again.

Pros:
- quite easy to set up, no need for specialist pdf software
- decent print quality

Cons:
- slow delivery
- high unit cost
- very expensive delivery – this is the main thing that defeats the POD aim IMO – just to print and ship a single copy of the 100-page book cost in excess of £10, without any markup at all. In fairness there was a cheaper (althoug not cheap) option which I selected for one of our proofs, and it didn’t arrive! We worked around this by ordering in bulk, but as I said, this kind of defeats the point.

Comment by Lillie
2008-10-21 11:32:36

Rodney,
Thanks for sharing your experience. The voice of someone who has actually tried this is a great contribution to the conversation because all I can share is what I’ve heard—not personal experience. Breaking down the pros and cons was helpful.

 
 
Comment by Rodney Smith Subscribed to comments via email
2008-10-21 11:44:47

No problem, Lillie. I might mention that a lot of the research we did prior to the fact indicated that LightningSource was the best choice. Unfortunately their submission requirements are very daunting – a lot of very technical pdf requirements – that were a bit beyond our expertise. I still believe they’re the best choice if one has a commercial motivation though.

Comment by Lillie
2008-10-21 11:48:15

Rodney,
The first publisher for Stroke of Luck used Lightning Source. The publisher dealt with them so I have no experience working with them, but the quality of the books was good.

 
 

Responses to this post:

Please read the instructions below. For more information see my comment policy.

Please include your first name or nickname. This site uses KeywordLuv. See instructions below name field. If this is your first comment, it will be held for moderation. After your first comment is approved, future comments will not be moderated. If your comment doesn't appear within a day, e-mail Lillie—the comment may have been caught in spam.
Name (required)
This site uses KeywordLuv. Enter Your Name @ Your Keywords (Fill in the keywords you want to appear in your link) in the Name field to take advantage. The link will appear in the post though not in the preview; if you see a mistake after the comment is posted, you have 15 minutes to edit your comment.
E-mail (required - never shown publicly)
URI
Subscribe to comments via email
Your Comment (smaller size | larger size)
You may use <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong> in your comment.

If you have not previously left a comment that has been approved, your comment will not appear until I have approved the first one.

CommentLuv Enabled

This site uses KeywordLuv. Enter YourName@YourKeywords in the Name field to take advantage.